Skip to main content

practical-scenarios

Workplace Ethical Dilemmas: INTJ Fi Solutions​

As an INTJ, you're going to face situations where your Fi values scream "Wrong!" while profit-driven corporate tactics win the day. Here's how to handle common scenarios:

Scenario 1: Price-Gouging Medication​

Your pharma company wants to charge an obscene price for a life-saving drug.

  • INTJ Strategy: Don't just argue for compassion. Frame it strategically: tiered pricing, patient outreach programs, etc. Show them long-term reputation is also profit.
  • The Hard Question: Can you live with working for a company that puts greed above lives, even if you mitigate it slightly?

Scenario 2: Ecologically Destructive Expansion​

Your company wants to expand into a sensitive area. You're tasked with the impact assessment.

  • INTJ Strategy: Thoroughly document long-term damage. Propose sustainable alternatives that still fuel growth.
  • The Hard Question: If leadership ignores you, your name is still attached to the project. Are you okay with that?

Scenario 3: Lying to Customers​

Your marketing team is launching a deceptive campaign.

  • INTJ Strategy: Gather hard evidence (false claims, etc.). Approach them constructively, suggesting honest messaging that still highlights the product.
  • The Hard Question: If they won't change, are you willing to be the whistleblower, even if it risks your job?

Scenario 4: Manipulative Website Design​

Your UX team prioritizes addictive 'dark patterns' over genuine user empowerment.

  • INTJ Strategy: Document the tactics used, and how they violate trust. Partner with ethical UX experts to present better options that STILL boost engagement.
  • The Hard Question: Is this an outlier, or a sign of systemic rot within the company?

Scenario 5: Discriminatory Hiring Practices​

Your company is biased towards hiring candidates from privileged backgrounds, excluding qualified candidates from marginalized groups.

  • INTJ Strategy: Present data-driven arguments demonstrating the benefits of diversity and inclusion. Propose blind recruitment processes or diversity training to mitigate biases.
  • The Hard Question: Are you willing to risk your own position to advocate for equitable hiring practices?

Scenario 6: Exploitative Labor Practices​

Your company outsources production to factories with poor working conditions and low wages.

  • INTJ Strategy: Conduct thorough research on the ethical implications of the outsourcing practices. Advocate for audits of supplier factories and the implementation of fair labor standards.
  • The Hard Question: Can you reconcile working for a company that prioritizes profit over the well-being of workers?

Scenario 7: Data Privacy Concerns​

Your company collects and monetizes user data without obtaining proper consent, potentially compromising user privacy.

  • INTJ Strategy: Highlight the legal and reputational risks associated with unethical data practices. Propose transparent data policies and opt-in/opt-out mechanisms for users.
  • The Hard Question: Are you prepared to challenge the status quo and potentially face backlash from company leadership?

Scenario 8: Environmental Impact Ignorance​

Your company disregards environmental regulations and contributes to pollution and resource depletion.

  • INTJ Strategy: Compile evidence of the environmental impact of the company's operations. Advocate for sustainable practices, renewable energy initiatives, and environmental impact assessments.
  • The Hard Question: How do you balance your commitment to environmental stewardship with the practical realities of business operations?

Scenario 9: Conflict of Interest​

Your company engages in partnerships or investments with entities known for unethical practices or human rights violations.

  • INTJ Strategy: Conduct due diligence on potential partners or investment opportunities, emphasizing the importance of ethical alignment. Advocate for divestment or ethical sourcing policies.
  • The Hard Question: Are you prepared to take a stand against lucrative business opportunities in the name of ethical integrity?

Scenario 10: Toxic Workplace Culture​

Your company tolerates bullying, harassment, or discrimination within the workplace.

  • INTJ Strategy: Document instances of misconduct and provide support to affected employees. Advocate for the implementation of clear anti-harassment policies and training programs.
  • The Hard Question: How do you navigate a toxic environment while striving to uphold your own values and principles?

Feel free to adapt these scenarios and strategies to fit your specific workplace context.

Overarching INTJ Tips​

  • Know Your Industry: What are ethical standards? This gives you solid ground for arguments.
  • Find Allies: You're not alone. Banding together gives you more leverage.
  • Hone Your Persuasion: INTJs need to sell their Fi-based ideas logically, not just emotionally.
  • Know Your Limits: When to compromise for the sake of impact, and when to walk away, is a vital INTJ skill.

This is HARD. Let's talk strategy if you're facing one of these dilemmas in real-time.